Features

State’s electricity market faces overhaul

The Associated Press
Saturday December 16, 2000

Federal regulators ordered an overhaul of California’s electricity market Friday to try to control skyrocketing prices that have pushed the state to the brink of blackouts this month. 

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s order will set a “soft” price cap on wholesale rates and let the state’s investor-owned utilities keep the power they generate rather than be forced to sell it on the open market, as they had to under California’s 1996 utility deregulation law. 

San Diego Gas and Electric, Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric together generate 25,000 megawatts a day, about 60 percent of what the state uses on a busy day and 90 percent on a slow day, FERC said. The state Public Utilities Commission would then set the price the utilities could charge customers. 

“Today’s order will staunch the hemorrhage and start rehabilitation” of California’s power market, FERC Chairman James Hoecker said. 

All three privately owned utilities have been hit hard by soaring wholesale electricity prices, blamed in part on tight supplies and rising natural gas costs. 

The San Diego utility’s customers have seen their bills double and even triple since summer; SoCal Edison and PG&E, operating under state-imposed rate freezes as they move toward deregulation, say they are in financial danger. 

Meanwhile, the Independent System Operator, keeper of California’s power grid, has found itself in an almost-daily scramble this month to find enough megawatts in the West to prevent rolling blackouts. Friday marked the first day in nearly two weeks the state had enough electricity to avoid declaring any level of power alert. 

The commission ordered a “soft cap” on wholesale electricity prices of $150 per megawatt hour. Suppliers offering to sell power in California at more than that price would have to file paperwork with FERC defending the higher price. 

In an effort to encourage investor-owned utilities to avoid last-minute buying, FERC ordered them to buy 95 percent of their power more than a day ahead of when it is needed. 

FERC also allowed them to enter into contracts with generators outside the state Power Exchange, which had been set up to oversee all power sales within the state. 

FERC suggested a contract price of $74 per megawatt hour for five years.  

This would be far lower than prices during the current crisis, but higher than during milder weather when supply is plentiful. 

“Rather than cap the spot market created by the state of California, we simply shrink its size, we diminish its influence,” Hoecker said. 

The commission agreed to participate in a Tuesday power summit requested by Energy Secretary Bill Richardson and Oregon Gov. Gov. John Kitzhaber. 

Various commissioners disagreed with parts of the order. 

Commissioner William Massey said the suggested contract price would be all right for two years, but that generators might be overpaid over five years. 

“This shouldn’t be looked at as a floor,” Massey said. 

FERC’s soft cap of $150 per megawatt hour on the electricity that is still sold through the Power Exchange will last for four months. During that period, regulators will study the open market to determine whether prices are still “unjust and unreasonable,” as they found in setting the order.